Skip to main content

Daniel Jones fiasco exposes a Colts problem they can't escape

It could only get worse.
ByLee Vowell
Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones at a press conference
Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones at a press conference | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Indianapolis Colts decided to take the nuclear option with Daniel Jones. Instead of simply benching the struggling quarterback, the team released him.

The move came 10 days after the NFL trade deadline, when Indy could have just dealt the QB elsewhere and gotten some draft value back. That didn't happen, and it exposes what could be a long-term problem for the Colts: Poor ownership decisions.

This isn't about the daughter of Jim Irsay taking over the team and maybe not knowing how to run an organization well. Even Jim made his share of mistakes. Every owner does, but some choose not to involve themselves in football decisions too much and let the football people make the football decisions.

Indianapolis Colts missed a golden opportunity by not trading Daniel Jones

CEO Carlie Irsay-Gordon, specifically, has reportedly been heavily involved in what the team should do after general manager Chris Ballard was fired in October. Irsay-Gordon didn't allow Jones to be traded but did allow his release. In essence, Indianapolis could have gotten something for Jones but instead chose to get nothing.

According to ESPN's Adam Schefter, the Baltimore Ravens had offered a fourth-round pick for Jones and a fifth-round choice. Had Baltimore made the playoffs after the move, then the fifth-round pick would have been returned to Indy.

How likely would that have been? Maybe not high, but high enough for Indianapolis to take a risk. One would hope that the decision to give up on Jones wasn't a knee-jerk reaction to what happened in Week 11 against the Houston Texans. That kind of move should have been mulled over for weeks.

During those weeks, the Ravens likely made their offer, and if there was even a chance that Jones wasn't going to finish the season with Indy, the trade should have been agreed to. What might have gummed up the works is ownership being too involved in the decision.

If the Ravens had offered a fourth-round pick for a fifth-round pick, the Colts would have taken that, right?

Adding in Jones only makes the offer sweeter because of the quarterback's massive contract. Indy saves $38 million by either releasing Jones or trading him, according to Over the Cap, and at least Indianapolis would have moved up one round in the 2027 draft by letting Jones go to Baltimore.

The Indianapolis Colts are better off letting Daniel Jones go. Except for the first half of last season, he has never hinted that he has the ability to lead a team long-term. He began to diminish in form even before he broke his fibula and then tore his Achilles tendon last season.

Instead, Chris Ballard thought that Jones was all fixed and overpaid to bring him back in the offseason. Carlie Irsay-Gordon helping decide that Jones needed to be removed from the roster was the right move, but not trading him when the chance presented itself nearly wipes away any good from the release of the quarterback.

In the future, Colts ownership needs to allow the people it hires to run the team to make the choices about what to do with the roster and coaching staff. Otherwise, Indy is going to keep making the same kind of mistakes it made with Jones.

Add us as a preferred source on Google