Entering Week 11, Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones was hoping that he could recapture some of the magic from his first game against the Houston Texans this year back in September. While not perfect, that was one of Jones’ better performances in a season that has been wildly disappointing. It was also the Colts’ first win of the year.
Unfortunately for Jones, Thursday night’s AFC South matchup was not a repeat of Week 3. Houston hammered Indianapolis in a 26-3 rout, and Jones continued an embarrassingly bad stretch of play.
While the Texans were favored to win and their defense was expected to create problems for Jones, this beatdown was still a nightmare result. Yet another disastrous outing for Jones and a loss for the Colts might mean it’s finally time for change in Indianapolis, one which was made on Friday.
3 definitive reasons Indianapolis Colts had to move on from Daniel Jones
Daniel Jones just had his worst game yet
Somehow, Jones kept outdoing himself every week — except he was going in the wrong direction. After Jones posted the lowest QB rating of any 2026 NFL starter last week, he continued his downward slide with another brutal performance against Houston.
Jones finished the game with zero touchdowns, an interception, and just 12 completions from 27 attempts before he was benched in the fourth quarter. His 44.4% completion rate was his worst mark of the season. Just when you thought Jones couldn't get any worse, he continued to surprise Indianapolis.
The rest of the Indianapolis offense is suffering
It’s the quarterback’s job to elevate the play of his teammates, but Jones was doing the opposite. The best (healthy) players on the Indianapolis offense — running back Jonathan Taylor and tight end Tyler Warren — are in the middle of their own individual slumps, largely because Jones’ play was handicapping the entire offense.
Warren only caught one pass in Houston and hasn’t crossed 50 receiving yards in four straight games. Three-time Pro Bowler Taylor just had the worst game of his season, running for a grand total of 21 yards. Taylor also hasn’t crossed the 100-yard mark yet all year, which would be a career-first if he ends the season that way.
When Jones is an absolute non-threat to the defense, there is no chance that even elite playmakers like Warren and Taylor can succeed.
Colts have nothing to lose
Until Friday, Indianapolis was still backing Jones as their starter week after week, even though the numbers kept getting worse and the losses continued to pile up. After falling to 3-8, the Colts’ season is a lost cause, and the team needs to think about what’s best for its future.
Maybe head coach Shane Steichen thought Jones could actually be a part of that future; there was no reason for him to start Jones in Week 12 against the Giants. Sure, Anthony Richardson may not be any better, but Indianapolis at least is giving him a look. It’s not like he can be that much worse than Jones.
