With another team for another franchise, Shane Steichen might very well be gone by now. Yet, with the Indianapolis Colts, he's kept his job to this point, even after former general manager Chris Ballard's firing.
Steichen has never lived through more than one winning season with the Colts since taking over head coaching duties in 2023. In his first season, the Colts went 9-8 but missed the playoffs; since then, they went 8-9 in two straight seasons and, so far, 3-8 this season.
Colts fans were hoping Steichen would snap the Colts' five-year playoff drought. Instead, it's about to be six years, and with offseason changes certainly ahead, Steichen is likely on the way out. That said, does his tenure in Indianapolis hurt his chances at another job? Or are there factors that lean in his favor for something good next year?
Shane Steichen has two key factors working for him if the Indianapolis Colts fire him
The question is: Is Steichen a bad head coach? Or is his considerable underperformance in Indianapolis more franchise-related than him-related? It could be both; however, there may be more evidence pointing to the latter than the former.
First, Steichen has shown in the past that he has a solid offensive pedigree, and that's the first element working in his favour for future coaching possibilities. The best quarterback Steichen has worked with in the NFL is Jalen Hurts. Remember, Hurts had his best statistical regular season in 2022 when the Eagles went to their first of two Super Bowls in three years.
Steichen was the brains behind Philadelphia's offense, and frankly, Hurts has never looked the same since. That's why, if the Eagles fire Nick Sirriani in the offseason and the Colts do the same to Steichen, Philadelphia presents an intriguing and fitting option for Steichen to land another head coaching job.
Stiechen's offensive acumen got him the Colts job to begin with, and it could get him another; he just hasn't had the talent at quarterback to likely keep the one he currently has, which leads to the second element that works in his favour.
Over Steichen's three-and-a-half-year tenure in Indianapolis, he's worked with one of the least talented teams across the league. That's not to say there are no talented players on the Colts—Jonathan Taylor and Alec Pierce, on offense specifically, are clearly talented, but nowhere near enough to make the Colts a competitive playoff contender.
Furthermore, Steichen has never had a top-10 or even top-15 quarterback to work with. Gardner Minshew, Joe Flacco (well past his prime), and Daniel Jones don't exactly scream explosive-offense-here-we-come. Of course, we can't forget Philip Rivers's mini-stint last season. While it was fun for nostalgia purposes, it fell dead.
For the entirety of Steichen's Colts tenure, roster construction has been, in a word, poor. Which begs the question: if he had even a mid-league-level roster to work with, what could be done? We saw the beginnings of that with the Eagles. Could we see it again elsewhere?
Steichen, while seemingly safe for now, is almost certainly out the door in the offseason; it would be a shock if Indianapolis retained him. That said, a firing doesn't always mean the end, and for Steichen, if those two factors really do side with him, it may not be long before he lands another head coaching job, and someone else will have to pick up the pieces in Indianapolis.
