Skip to main content

3 Colts who proved they aren't the answer in Week 11 rout

Well, that was ugly
ByFinnegan Twomey
Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen leaves the field
Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen leaves the field | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Every Indianapolis Colts fan should mark down the date November 19, 2026. That day is the exact moment when any last vestige of hope for Shane Steichen to be the coach of the future for the team was brutally eviscerated

The Colts lost in primetime against a 3-6 divisional opponent by a score of 26-3. Really, the only reason the Colts even seemed to be on the field was to help showcase the Houston Texans' spiffy new rivalry uniforms.

This was a game that was more reminiscent of the Harlem Globetrotters showing off against the Washington Generals than an actually competitive professional football game.

3 Indianapolis Colts who proved what we already knew in Week 11

Though the Colts won in Week 10 against the lowly Miami Dolphins, it's never been clearer that there is simply no short-term future for this team. The Colts and the Texans might both have come into Week 11 with three wins, but the difference in quality between each squad was stark.

Demeco Ryans had his team humming with energy from the start. The Colts looked like they had already conceded defeat halfway through the second quarter.

No. 1: HC Shane Steichen

Shane Steichen had a good run for a while as the Indianapolis Colts head coach. That run should not be allowed to continue any longer. Stalwart supporters of Steichen can point to the dearth of talent on the roster as a reason why he should be given another chance.

Undoubtedly, the talent situation of the Colts squad is untenable, and very few coaches would be able to eke out good results week to week. That's not the point. The point is that it's clear in the players' body language nearly every week that they're already expecting defeat. This is a team that has quit on its leader, and it shows up in the play.

That's not to mention the mind-numbing, seemingly unending blind loyalty Steichen seems to have towards quarterback Daniel Jones. Jones has been statistically one of (if not the single) worst quarterbacks in the entirety of the NFL.

The man just put up a stat line of 144 yards and produced only 3 points. At some point, as a leader of men, one has to draw a line in the sand and say that this level of play is unacceptable.

Steichen refuses to draw that line, and because of it (and myriad other factors), players seem to be checked out of the season already.

No. 2: QB Daniel Jones

It's a Sisyphean task writing an article about the losers of the Colts' games most weeks, because unerringly, every single time, it's unjustifiable to leave Jones off that list. No matter who the most productive quarterback in the Colts stable has been in the past, it's a minor miracle for the offense to even get in field goal range.

In a lost season, at least try to infuse some life, some energy into the squad. With Jones at the helm, the energy of the whole team is nothing short of anemic. There are many Anthony Richardson detractors in the ranks of the Indianapolis Colts, and understandably so.

Not only that, there seems to be a rift between Richardson and Steichen that will never be bridged. One need only to look at Richardson standing away from the rest of the team on the sidelines to know that.

Even so, there's another quarterback on the roster. It's clear Jones isn't the answer, and it's clear Steichen won't turn to Anthony Richardson for any sort of potential spark. In a season where the evaluation of key young players like CJ Allen has become priority number one, why not see what a young quarterback in Riley Leonard can do?

Worst-case scenario, he's as bad as Jones has been. Best case, he infuses some spark of life into the team.

Make no mistake, Shane Steichen is coaching for his job, and Daniel Jones will not save it. Whether it be Richardson or Leonard, fans of the team are begging for any change in the status quo.

No. 3: RB Jonathan Taylor

It's painful to put the man who is clearly the most talented player on the Colts roster here, the man who has been the brightest star for Indy throughout the 2020's. Running behind a piecemeal offensive line held together by silly string and bubble gum, it's nigh impossible for Jonathan Taylor to do anything.

The man doesn't have a chance on nearly every play run. The line is like a sieve, and the instant he touches the ball, there are defenders bearing down on him. Still, that doesn't change the final stat line of 11 rushes for 21 yards. The offense, as previously mentioned, was anemic. It's become evident that Taylor is still a very good player in a terrible situation.

Still, with the emergence of RB Seth McGowan (who unfortunately left the contest against Houston early with injury), the abysmal performance of the team, and at the age of 27 years old, it's become mind-boggling that the Colts didn't trade him for the reported package of a second-round pick and more that they were offered at the trade deadline.

Especially in a year with no first-round pick, few promising young assets, and no wins to be had solely from Taylor's being on the team, any draft capital that could be recouped would have been a win. The team was willing to trade a franchise icon in Quentin Nelson for a third and a fifth, and DeForest Buckner for a fourth-round pick.

Both of these moves brought in draft capital that was lower than the player's perceived value. So why reject a legitimately good trade offer for an aging running back at the peak of his value just to keep him on a losing team that puts up 3 points on offense?

It will be a long road back to relevancy, Colts fans. Time to buckle in.

Add us as a preferred source on Google