Most Overrated Colts Players in Madden ’18


With Madden ’18 hitting the shelves in time for the regular season, we looked at the Colts’ most overrated players according to this year’s ratings.

RB Frank Gore: 83 Overall

There’s no question that Frank Gore has had an incredible career during his 12 NFL seasons, but rating him at an 83 overall is a bit high at 34 years of age. He has a speed rating of 82 and an acceleration rating of 88, which are both a bit high.

A couple of ratings that are spot on, however, are his awareness and toughness ratings that both come in at 97. Gore is a fantastic professional and it’s amazing that he’s still playing at this level, but 83 overall seems a bit ridiculous.

WR Kamar Aiken: 78 Overall

The Colts were hoping they were getting a receiver that was deserving of a 78 overall rating when they signed Kamar Aiken this offseason, but he hasn’t been very impressive thus far in his tenure in Indianapolis.

He was expected to come in and take the third wide receiver spot, but he currently sits behind Chester Rogers on the depth chart, who is listed at 67 overall in Madden ’18. Aiken could prove this rating was correct with a big year, but that doesn’t seem likely.

Next: Indianapolis Colts Complete Madden ’18 Ratings

OLB Barkevious Mingo: 78 Overall

It’s hard to believe that Barkevious Mingo deserves a 78 overall rating when he’s already been cut by two teams in his four year NFL career.

Mingo had the talent to be taken sixth overall in the 2013 NFL Draft, but he has yet to show that high level of potential on an NFL field.