Harold Fannin Jr. (Cleveland Browns), Michael Mayer (Las Vegas Raiders), Colston Loveland (Chicago Bears), and Brenton Strange (Jacksonville Jaguars) are the group of young tight ends who have made a huge jump in the NFL this season, but where is Indianapolis Colts TE Tyler Warren?
One of the biggest bright spots for the Colts last season was Warren's explosive rookie season—817 receiving yards (a franchise record for a Colts tight end), 76 targets, four touchdowns, and 10.8 yards per catch. Warren exceeded expectations in every category as a rookie and made his first NFL season look like a five-year veteran's.
Because of his rookie season, many labelled it Warren's pre-breakthrough year, which subsequently drove up expectations for his second year. Warren was supposed to make an even bigger jump, if he could, and become one of the league's best tight ends just in his second year. Unfortunately, it hasn't happened, and Warren hasn't given Colts fans what they were expecting.
Indianapolis Colts' TE Tyler Warren continued his sophomore slump against the Miami Dolphins
Warren has one defense, despite his second season's decreased production: the Colts offense simply isn't good, and Daniel Jones also simply hasn't been good enough to make the Colts offense good. Jones is posting some of the worst numbers of his career this season, which will naturally trickle down to the receivers and tight ends and impact their production.
Warren has clearly been on the losing end of this deal, but it only continued in Week 10, when he had his worst game of the season. On just two receptions on three targets, Warren totaled one yard. Jones also threw for an abysmal 108 yards, though, which, given the Colts' other wide receivers' numbers, makes sense when you look at Warren's.
Warren has only two games this season where he's gone over 50 receiving yards. He hasn't caught a touchdown since Week 2 (he has two on the year) and has only 40 receptions in 10 games. Again, much of this is due to the Colts' dispiriting offence, but it glaringly shows how off the offseason predictions and projections were.
Based on last season, Warren was primed to break through into the NFL's group of top tight ends, and so early into his career. It would have been a significant career development. Instead, his production looks like a regular tight end rookie season, a complete contrast to last season.
Going up against the Dolphins could have been Warren's best game of the year for two reasons. One, the Dolphins have struggled mightily to defend tight ends all season. Two, the Colts have a depleted wide receiver room, and Warren, although a tight end, is without question the team's best pass-catcher, with Alec Pierce still out. Yet, Jones managed 108 yards; Warren: one.
Again, it's not all on Warren. That said, even amid the Colts' offensive struggles, fans in Indianapolis were surely hoping and expecting more than Warren has delivered. Does it negate all that he did in his rookie year? Of course, not. Last season was hardly a fluke.
The question has to be asked, though: if the Colts had a better offensive system and a better quarterback, would Warren's numbers still look the way they do, or would they be much more attractive? It's hard to imagine the answer being the former.
