Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen knows how to run a successful offense. He proved that before he came to Indy in 2023, but he still has to have quality players to carry out his plans. At wide receiver in the coming season, his group is pretty thin, just an injury away from crashing the overall team.
Indy had to do something with wide receiver Michael Pittman this offseason because his $29 million cap hit was unacceptable for 2026. This was the team's fault, of course. General manager Chris Ballard is the one who set Indianapolis up for failure by offering Pittman a huge extension in 2024.
The receiver was traded to the Pittsburgh Steelers, but the team hasn't done much to replace him. The Colts are hoping that Alec Pierce, who signed his own new deal with Indy this offseason for four seasons and as much as $116 million, can take a big jump in production moving forward.
Indianapolis Colts are a wide receiver injury away from a terrible situation
An explosive player, Pierce still has never had 50 catches in a season, and just one season with more than 1,000 yards. That was last season when the wideout finished with 1,003. Can Pierce be a versatile WR1? No one knows, and he must stay healthy.
Josh Downs is a solid slot receiver who could get more looks in 2026, but he isn't the kind of receiver who is going to challenge defenses on the outside. He simply isn't big enough to do that at 5'9" and 175 pounds.
After Pierce and Downs are a lot of players who appear to be meh. None is going to scare defensive coordinators. Ballard signed free agent Nick Westbrook-Ikhine, but he's never had more than 38 catches in a single season, and that was in 2021. The team took Deion Burks in the 2026 draft, but not until the seventh round.
Should Alec Pierce or Josh Downs get injured, the Indianapolis Colts are in real trouble. Tight end Tyler Warren, for instance, is a good receiver, sure, but he isn't going to line up outside in a receiver spot very often. He's more Downs than Pierce in terms of positional flexibility.
Defenses began to adjust to what the Colts were doing last season, even before quarterback Daniel Jones was hurt in Week 14. It is easy to forget that even before his torn Achilles tendon ended his season, the team was on the outside of the playoff picture, though Indy started 7-1.
Opponents didn't keep believing that Jones could beat them on his own, and loaded up the box to stop running back Jonathan Taylor. As Taylor was less effective, so was the offense, and a mediocre defense wasn't capable of winning close games.
Indianapolis simply needs another wide receiver to step up to take up some of the slack left by trading Michael Pittman. No player on the current roster might be able to do that.
Indianapolis still has some cash to spend this offseason, and free agent options are available. Stefon Diggs and Deebo Samuel are decent options. At least they have the experience to help move the ball. Otherwise, the Colts are stuck with what they have, and that might not be good enough.
Add us as a preferred source on Google