The Indianapolis Colts have a problem at edge rusher, one that has been a long-term problem because fired general manager Chris Ballard kept whiffing on players in various drafts. One player who didn't seem like a miss, though, was Laiatu Latu. That presumption might be wrong.
In 2025, Latu was very good. He had 8.5 sacks and 12 tackles for loss, and many times was the only threat at edge rusher. That means he should have been the same threat this season, especially since Jaylahn Tuimoloau has played far better than last season. Instead, Latu has not been nearly good enough.
He has three sacks through 11 games, but only one tackle for loss. He disappears for long stretches of time. In Week 11 against the Houston Texans, Latu was credited with five pressures, all quarterback hurries and no QB hits, but he didn't record a single tackle. He missed on his only attempt. That is inexcusable.
Indianapolis Colts' Laiatu Latu has taken a step back in 2026
Defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo blitzed a bit more against Houston, though ultimately that didn't help the situation. He should have been able to rely on a solid pass rush with Latu ascending beginning last year, but that hasn't developed.
Some of the fault lies with Anarumo, too. It is his job to help a young player grow into a great one. While that seemed to be happening last season, Latu has taken a step back this year. Forget any positive grades Latu might receive; fans can see how inconsistent he is.
Through 11 games, compared to the 16 he played in 2025, Latu has half as many total pressures, has as many run stuffs, fewer than half as many sacks, and can't make a sustained high-end impact in any game. Is this the player he is, or was his version last season truly who he can be?
Maybe he needs a better scheme to work in or a better defensive direction. Still, he was good in his first season playing in Anarumo's system, so what has happened this season? As a first-round pick, Laiatu Latu has to be one of the players that the Colts can count on as a foundational piece in future seasons.
He is signed through 2027, but the team has a fifth-year option on him. That decision needs to be made next offseason, and the assumption is that Indianapolis will pick it up, keeping Latu with the team through 2028.
Has he earned that? He didn't produce much as a rookie, was good in year two, but not as good in year three. Is he another draft miss by Chris Ballard, or maybe Latu just needs a defensive coordinator who can use him better?
We will find all the answers to those questions in 2027 when the Indianapolis Colts likely have a new coaching staff. Laiatu Latu could help rebuild the defense and be a long-term star. Otherwise, he might be out of Indy by the time 2028 is done, replaced by a player who offers more consistent production.
