The Indianapolis Colts traded for cornerback Sauce Gardner midway through 2025 in hopes he would provide elite man coverage and help build the defense from the back to the front. Through a full calendar year, the trade has been one of the worst in recent team memory.
Not only has the cornerback been inconsistent in his quality of coverage, but he's been hurt quite a bit. Specifically, his calf. He has now hurt his left calf three times, forcing him to miss games each time.
Last season, he missed four of a possible eight games after the trade. This year, he has missed one so far, but that is likely to change. He injured his calf in Indy's Week 10 victory against the Miami Dolphins, and while the team isn't expected to put him on injured reserve, he is trending toward missing Thursday's game against the Houston Texans and likely more.
Sauce Gardner's underwhelming performance and mounting injuries are a real problem for the Indianapolis Colts
Hurting the same calf a couple of times is the start of a worrying trend. Injuring the same calf three times in 12 months might make one wonder if Gardner is going to have a long-term issue because of some deeper problem.
Without question, for the trade to work for Gardner, he has to be constantly healthy and elite at his job. He has not been so far. The Colts traded two first-round draft picks and wide receiver Adonai Mitchell to the New York Jets for the cornerback, and that has already been a bust. For the second season in a row, Indy won't be going to the playoffs after adding Gardner.
He is still under contract through 2030, with cap hits of nearly $21 million in 2027 and growing to $36.1 million in 2029 and 2030. Indianapolis could trade the cornerback in hopes of getting decent draft value back for him, though a trade couldn't happen until the offseason at this point; a team has to be willing to take on the corner's salary.
Making any potential trade more difficult, Gardner's performance, coupled with his injuries, hasn't been what any team would want. His quarterback rating allowed this season is 104.2, and he's been called for five penalties. Even against a Miami team with a quarterback taking the first snaps of his career, Gardner was called for two penalties.
The next games (or games) could be telling. Will the Indianapolis Colts miss having Sauce Gardner on the field? His performance doesn't imply the team will miss him, at least not very much.
That's a real problem. A player worth that much draft capital should be excellent every game and unquestionably one of the best in the NFL. In 13 games with the Colts, Sauce Gardner has allowed three touchdown passes but has no interceptions, and the latter has never been a strength of his (he has three interceptions in his five-year career).
Gardner needs to be better, but he can't be if he is not on the field. He appears unlikely to be on Thursday Night Football in Week 11.
