Skip to main content

Colts' Week 10 clash with Dolphins produces 4 winners and 2 losers

Mostly decent.
ByLee Vowell
Indianapolis Colts running back Seth McGowan reacts after rushing for a touchdown
Indianapolis Colts running back Seth McGowan reacts after rushing for a touchdown | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Indianapolis Colts would have no real reason to lose to the Miami Dolphins. While Indy's wide receiver corps was exceedingly weak after trades at the deadline, nearly all of Miami's roster is the equivalent of the current state of Indianapolis's receivers.

Maybe the Colts aren't going to the playoffs this season, but fans can still celebrate random victories. The expectation was that Week 10 would mean the team would be 3-7 ahead of Week 11's Thursday Night Football game against the Houston Texans.

While Indy's 24-22 victory against the Dolphins might have been against one of the worst NFL teams in recent memory, it still took players performing well to make that happen. For the first time in seemingly years, Indianapolis has more winners from a game than losers.

Winners and losers for the Indianapolis Colts against the Miami Dolphins

Winner: The Colts running attack

Let's be real: Head coach Shane Steichen should have run the ball a lot more than he has this season. Daniel Jones has mostly not been good, and Jonathan Taylor is the best player on the team anyway. Somewhat unexpectedly, seventh-round pick Seth McGowan has been good too.

Even behind an offensive line dealing with multiple injuries, Taylor and McGowan were able to run through and around the Dolphins effectively. Had the team begun the game by running the ball earlier, Indianapolis could have been ahead comfortably. With a different approach in 2027 under a likely new head coach, Indy will run more, and that should lead to more wins.

Why Steichen continues to force the pass is unknown. The run would make the offense better every week. In Week 10, Taylor and McGowan combined to run 28 times for 160 yards and a touchdown.

Winner: Cornerback Justin Walley

Walley was solid throughout the game and played physically against the run. His role continues to grow after a pretty rough start to the season, but the Colts were wise to trust him with the slot corner spot.

He began the second half by hitting Dolphins quarterback Kyle McCord on a blitz and forcing a fumble that Adetomiwa Adebawore recovered for a touchdown. It was the kind of play that Walley should be asked to replicate often.

Winner: Linebacker CJ Allen

After being a healthy scratch for much of the first part of the season, Allen has begun to show why he was a smart choice for the Colts' first pick of the 2026 draft. He appears to be a bit of everywhere, stout against the run, and becoming better in coverage with every week. He had a pass defended and a tackle for loss against Miami, and should only continue to get better.

Allen got stronger as the game wore on, too. He basically finished the game with a sack when Miami was trying to drive to get the lead. If not for a penalty on another player away from the play, Allen would have had a fantastic pick-six, too.

Winner: Wide receiver Laquon Treadwell

Was Treadwell monumental to the success of the offense? Not really, but he did score on a touchdown catch, his first TD since 2021, and just the sixth of his long career. He's been a grinder for much of his NFL life, and deserves any success he gets.

Loser: Cornerback Sauce Gardner

The 2025 acquisition keeps being less impressive than Indianapolis hoped he would be. His first half was rather rough, with a couple of penalties (one was refused) and getting beat in coverage. He is too good to consistently allow that to happen.

Maybe he is feeling the pressure of the team giving up two first-round picks to get him, but he has to be better in future years. He's capable of brilliance, but has leveled off in form recently.

Loser: Quarterback Daniel Jones

What a miserable season for Jones, who shouldn't be back with the team next season. Releasing him would save the team $38 million, and no new general manager should be hamstrung by having Jones as QB1.

The quarterback had two more interceptions, both his fault. One didn't matter as it came on a fourth down attempt. The other did, as Jones threw off-target to tight end Drew Ogletree in the third quarter, and the ball bounced off the TE's hands and into the arms of Chris Johnson, who returned the ball for a touchdown.

Add us as a preferred source on Google