Skip to main content

Colts will regret not replacing Shane Steichen with Reggie Wayne already

What's the hold-up?
ByErnesto Cova
Indianapolis Colts wide receiver coach Reggie Wayne before a game
Indianapolis Colts wide receiver coach Reggie Wayne before a game | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Indianapolis Colts entered this season with more pressure than most teams. Following an 8-2 start to the 2025 season and after the now-infamous Sauce Gardner trade, plenty of seats were blazing hot in Circle City.

The Colts fired general manager Chris Ballard in Week 6, but surprisingly, they kept Shane Steichen. However, he has done little to help his case in the past month, looking like someone who knows he won't be back next season.

That's why it's kind of baffling to see the Colts haven't already turned to Reggie Wayne. Steichen looks overwhelmed, and it seems that he's already given up on this team; it's about time they shake things up.

The Indianapolis Colts must give Reggie Wayne a shot to show what he's got

Reggie Wayne is a former Super Bowl winner, six-time Pro-Bowler, former All-Pro wide receiver who, over 14 years, went on to set Colts franchise records for most regular-season games played (211), wins (143), 1,000-yard seasons (tied for eighth), postseason receptions (93), playoff receiving yards (1,254), and playoff touchdown catches (nine).

Does that make him qualified to be a head coach? Probably not, but he's been with the organization since the Frank Reich regime. Everyone in the building knows and respects him, and he's been instrumental in developing guys like Alec Pierce, Josh Downs, and Michael Pittman Jr.

This is probably already a wasted season for the Colts. They shouldn't care about draft positioning because they don't have a first-round pick, and they should keep an open mind about potential head-coaching candidates.

So, if Steichen's days are already numbered, why not cut him loose and get this over with? What's the hold-up? And more importantly, what is it there to win by keeping Steichen instead of showing him the door when everyone knows he won't return?

Steichen deserved the benefit of the doubt for keeping this team hovering around .500 and in the playoff race with a revolving door of mediocre quarterbacks, but he's been pretty bad for nearly two seasons now.

Some guys are better suited for top assistant coaching jobs, and there's nothing wrong with that. He will likely land on his feet and find a gig as an offensive coordinator in 2027 or 2028, but he clearly isn't head-coaching material.

So, assuming Wayne is interested in pursuing a career in coaching, why not give him two months to show what he's got? Why not let him take care of that locker room and see whether he can make the guys believe and play hard again?

Wayne is a franchise legend, which doesn't mean he'll be the right guy for the job (i.e., Jeff Saturday). That said, he's already been there during two different regimes, and it's not like he can do much worse than what we've seen so far.

Add us as a preferred source on Google