The Indianapolis Colts are battling for a spot in the playoffs, and potentially as champions of the AFC South. Currently, the Houston Texans are on top of the division, but the lead they hold over the Colts is slim, and the Texans are facing more tough opponents in the remaining weeks of the season than the Colts are. Both teams are facing divisional match-ups in the last week of the season -- the Colts against the Jacksonville Jaguars and the Texans against the Tennessee Titans -- so if the Colts go on a winning streak, it's entirely possible that they could end up winning the AFC South.
This weekend, however, the Texans played the Jaguars, and created headlines for all the wrong reasons. Linebacker Azeez Al-Shaair was ejected from the game after a late hit on quarterback Trevor Lawrence that left Lawrence seemingly unconconscious, at least momentarily, and posturing, a sign of a traumatic brain injury. It was later confirmed that Lawrence did suffer a concussion, and many are now calling for the NFL to institute a harsher punishment.
The hit: was it dirty?
Watch Trevor Lawrence immediately after this horrific hit. His right arm suddenly flexes as his left arm simultaneously extends. This is known as the “fencing posture”—an involuntary reflex that occurs after impact in blunt head trauma. It signifies a traumatic brain injury with… pic.twitter.com/Saa8j8cffJ
— Sam Ghali, M.D. (@EM_RESUS) December 1, 2024
The hit caused immediate chaos, with Evan Engram and the rest of the Jacksonville team flooding the field to stand up for their QB, causing a massive fight and, eventually, several ejections.
It didn't take long for analysts, former players, and fans alike to react, almost all agreeing that Al-Ashaair was in the wrong.
The league reacts
I’ve been covering the NFL for 48 years and I can’t remember a cheap shot worse than what Al-Shaair did to Lawrence. He’ll be lucky to avoid a suspension.
— John McClain (@McClain_on_NFL) December 1, 2024
Fans at the game were understandably furious.
#Jaguars fans were throwing objects on Azeez Al-Shaair as he left the field: pic.twitter.com/qkcAm5Ywfh https://t.co/a90Z1qTydi
— Ari Meirov (@MySportsUpdate) December 1, 2024
Former players likewise said this hit was unnecessary.
That’s bull by Azeez Al-Shaair!! You just dive over the QB’s head when they slide. You make sure they go down but you don’t go to the players helmet like that. I 100% agree with an ejection.
— Ryan Clark (@Realrclark25) December 1, 2024
And 100% there’s supposed to be a fight! Jaguars did the right thing.
Many people compared it to the Kiko Alonso hit on Joe Flacco.
The hit Trevor Lawrence took today reminds me of the worst shot I ever saw a QB take live: Kiko Alonso vs Joe Flacco pic.twitter.com/TN7xNlJSWp
— Elisha Surillo (@elishasurillo) December 1, 2024
Al-Ashaair apologizes... sort of
The man in the middle of the controversy took to X with an apology written on his Notes app, that mostly avoided taking any responsibility for the situation and, even worse, labeled fans as racist and Islamophobic for criticizing the hit.
He said his goal is always to "hit you as hard as I can," though he hopes his opponents can still go home unharmed afterwards, saying it wasn't personal, but "just competition." Though he did add an apology, he also claimed he didn't notice Lawrence sliding until it was too late, and that it all happened too fast.
All Praise to Allah🤲🏾 pic.twitter.com/pEbCRAg8fF
— Azeez Al-shaair (@A_train2_) December 2, 2024
Any goodwill he may have been able to garner with his apology was erased, however, when he began playing the victim himself.
"To the rest of the people who I've been called every name in the book from the reporters with their hands ready for a story to find their villain, to racist and Islamophobic fans and people, you don't know my heart nor my character which I don't need to prove to any of you," he wrote.
This actually is what the Texans stand for
Texans head coach DeMeco Ryans responded by arguing that this wasn't the kind of football he coaches and that it doesn't represent who Al-Ashaair is. “It’s unfortunate with the hit. … That’s not what we’re coaching,” Ryans said. “Want to be smart in everything we do and not hurt the team. … We just have to be smarter when the quarterback is going down."
He continued, “Not representative of who Azeez is. He's is a smart player, really a great leader for us. We felt his presence not being there. His loss, it really affected us on the defensive side. Not what we’re coaching, you don't want to see the melee, the aftermath. That’s not what we’re about. We’ll move forward.”
#Texans coach DeMeco Ryans on Azeez Al-Shaair hit on Trevor Lawrence 'unfortunate, not representative of who we are' said he'll speak to him about it @KPRC2 pic.twitter.com/PaCClSXDne
— Aaron Wilson (@AaronWilson_NFL) December 1, 2024
Many pointed out that this is, in fact, normal behavior from Al-Ashaair, pointing specifically to a game against the Chicago Bears earlier this season, where he not only executed the same kind of dirty hit on Caleb Williams, but also punched Roschon Johnson - who wasn't even playing at the time - in the face.
Full video of the hit on Caleb Williams and the punch by Azeez Al-Shaair on Roschon Johnson
— Drunk Ryan Poles (@DrunkRyanPoles) September 16, 2024
No flag was thrown on this play. Roschon was standing on the sideline - not even in the game. pic.twitter.com/TSef44R1jA
That’s great.
— Kirsten Tanis (@kct2020) December 2, 2024
When do you plan on apologizing to #Bears RB Roschon Johnson?
Who you hit with a right hook to the helmet on the sidelines in W2.
And Roschon wasn’t even on the field for the previous play? @roschon is still waiting. pic.twitter.com/iEcxonN0A2
A highlight reel of all the dirty plays conducted by Al-Ashaair was also put together and posted it on X.
Azeez Al-Shaair try not to be a dirty player challenge (impossible) pic.twitter.com/PI30RkpMr7
— NFL Memes (@NFL_Memes) December 2, 2024
While it could be claimed that this is on Al-Ashaair alone, the reality is that this behavior does reflect upon who the Texans are as an organization. Not only is he still allowed to play for them, but he was made a team captain in 2023, kept a team captain in 2024, and remained a captain after the dirty hit on Williams and punching Johnson in the face.
Given that, it seems clear that the Texans do, in fact, support his behavior. If this behavior was something they didn't condone, they would have taken action before, and even now, Ryans is defending Al-Ashaair as being a player of good character. So Ryans can say whatever he wants - the actions of his team speak much louder.