Chris Ballard had the opportunity to get two of the top ten linebacker prospects in the 2026 NFL Draft. And he passed on the chance. But there may be a method behind the apparent madness.
The Colts entered the draft in desperate need of linebacking help. Without Zaire Franklin and with Germaine Pratt still floating in free agent limbo, Lou Anarumo does not have much in the way of experience for the middle level of his defense.
Ballard began addressing the shortcoming with his first pick. He chose Georgia’s CJ Allen in the second round. Allen projects to be starting come opening day, 2026. Then Pittsburgh’s Kyle Louis began slipping and was sitting there when Ballard turned in the card for his second pick in round four. The Colts general manager did choose a linebacker, but it was not Louis.
Bryce Boettcher might be a better fit for the Colts’ defense than Kyle Louis
Oregon’s Bryce Boettcher is not exactly a major reach in round four. Most scouts had him pegged as a fourth or fifth-round pick. But Louis offers a more unique skill set, especially in terms of pass coverage. He is a smaller, quicker player than Boettcher.
It is possible that Anarumo views CJ Allen as his mobile centerfielder on defense. He could play an all-field role like Roquan Smith has provided for the Ravens. And if that is the case, having a bruiser like Boettcher playing alongside him might work out better than having the speedier Louis.
Boettcher is a beast. He is not merely bigger than Louis, he plays far bigger. He takes up space in the middle of the field and attacks downhill. He is never going to be able to run with speedier backs or slot receivers the way Louis can, but as an aggressive downhill run stopper, he could thrive.
Boettcher is not a polished player but he is productive. He plays with an edge. Every defense needs that. The Colts were pushed around last season, especially after losing Deforest Buckner late in the year.
The fact is, both of the Colts new linebackers will only be as effective as Buckner, Grover Stewart and the other rotational tackles allow them to be. If the interior of the Colts’ line keeps the young linebackers clean, they will have an excellent chance to make plays as rookies. If they don’t, then no one is going to thrive.
Kyle Louis is going to be a very interesting player to watch. It’s possible, given his size and unique gifts, that he may develop into a player more akin to Nick Emmanwori in Seattle. He may not really be a traditional linebacker in the NFL. He may play a hybrid safety/linebacker role that is appealing to so many teams as passing offenses grow more and more complex.
That is not why Chris Ballard drafted Bryce Boettcher. He drafted Boettcher to punish anyone who ventures into the middle of the Colts’ defense. In CJ Allen, he has an all-around backer who can be a star. In Boettcher, he has found a bodyguard for Allen – someone who can do the dirty work inside and let Allen fly around the field.
That’s the theory at least. It isn’t that Boettcher is a better player or better prospect than Allen. It’s simply that he may be a better fit for what the Colts need at this point.
Add us as a preferred source on Google