Skip to main content

Alec Pierce's season ends with the Colts decision everyone expected

Yeah, but...
ByLee Vowell
Indianapolis Colts wide receiver Alec Pierce adjusts his helmet
Indianapolis Colts wide receiver Alec Pierce adjusts his helmet | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

The Indianapolis Colts have ended wide receiver Alec Pierce's season, one he likely shouldn't have been playing in the first place.

One of many mistakes the former general manager Chris Ballard made, Pierce was re-signed to a four-year deal last offseason that will pay him as much as $114 million. The problem isn't that the player isn't capable of breaking his personal bests in catches and receiving yards, but that Ballard overpaid for him when he knew Pierce was hurt,

If Pierce had hit free agency but other teams knew about his injury, would they have offered him what Indy did? Probably not.

Indianapolis Colts will sit Alec Pierce for the rest of the season

A couple of weeks after signing his new deal, Pierce had surgery on his heel, an injury he had played through last season. He was expected to miss 4-6 months and return by the time the season began, but only if he was fully healthy and ready to play. He might have rushed back too quickly in five months and aggravated the issue almost immediately.

After a decent Week 1, Pierce got hurt in Week 2 and hasn't played since. According to NFL insider Ian Rapoport, the team will shut down the wide receiver for the remainder of the year.

Why did Indy feel the need to wait so long and only make the decision once quarterback Daniel Jones had been released? It was clear even to the most casual fans that after a dismal beginning to the season, Pierce had no business playing at all this season. It is better for him to fully recuperate and return next season.

His injury concern is simply another in a line of odd situations with Colts players. Jones, for instance, was allowed to play on a fractured fibula for a few games before tearing his Achilles tendon last season. Do the Colts put pressure on players to try to play even while hurt?

Maybe not, but that could be the public perception. Alec Pierce should have been able to miss some games when the season began, but after little practice, he was on the field when the Colts were destroyed by the Baltimore Ravens to open the season.

One of the biggest losers of the rest of the season with not having Pierce available for games is quarterback Anthony Richardson. He is the new QB1 with Jones gone, and Richardson is a free agent next offseason.

He will be trying to prove to the Indianapolis Colts or any other potential suitor that he is worthy of being signed, but he will be trying to find success while having the worst wide receiver group in the NFL. A healthy Pierce would have greatly helped the situation, but the receiver never had a real chance to do that this season.

The positive part is that Pierce is signed through 2029, hopefully he can be back to his best level in future seasons and not be hampered by a long-term heel injury. He will have a new quarterback throwing him the ball most likely, but he could be the WR1 that Indy didn't have in 2026.

Add us as a preferred source on Google