Is $750 a good deal for an autographed Peyton Manning jersey?

Fanatics /

$750 is a lot of money. But it might not be a lot of money for an authentic autographed Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts jersey.

Every once in awhile Fanatics adjusts some of the prices and inventory of their signed memorabilia. While checking it out recently, we discovered some autographed Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts jerseys. 

At first glance, it seemed like a good deal. $749.99 for the Mitchell & Ness autographed jersey. I mean, that’s a ton of money – but in comparison to other collectibles and memorabilia it seemed plenty reasonable.

Upon more research, it actually seems like a steal? Well, as much as nearly $1,000 can be a steal for something.

Fanatics /

Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Fanatics Authentic Autographed Mitchell & Ness Blue Replica Jersey

From Fanatics: This jersey has been personally hand-signed by Peyton Manning. It is officially licensed by the National Football League and comes with an individually numbered, tamper-evident hologram from Fanatics Authentic. To ensure authenticity, the hologram can be reviewed online. This process helps to ensure that the product purchased is authentic and eliminates any possibility of duplication or fraud.

Similarly, an autographed Aaron Rodgers Green Bay Packers jersey is more than $1,000 right now. An autographed Nikola Jokic Denver Nuggets jersey is $800. A Shohei Ohtani signed baseball shadowbox is $950.

A framed Josh Allen jersey is $1,050. Sure, professionally framing a jersey makes it look great… but you can get a quality jersey frame on Amazon for around $80.

That’s not to take anything away from the players mentioned above. Aaron Rodgers is a Hall of Famer, and one of the best quarterbacks of all-time. Jokic is insanely talented and a Hall of Famer. Ohtani is the biggest international baseball star – a true unicorn on the mound and the plate. And Allen is one of the best in the league today.

But Peyton Manning is on the quarterback Mount Rushmore. He’s almost universally considered one of the top three quarterbacks of all-time.

It just seems… off?

So I suppose if you’ve been itching to add some incredible memorabilia to your fan cave, you can get a mighty fine deal on a signed Peyton Manning jersey. 

This post contains affiliate links, where we may receive a percentage of any sale made from the links on this page. Prices and availability are accurate as of the time of publication.