Colts Free Agency Grades: How satisfied should Indy fans be?

Free Agency Grades: Indianapolis Colts returning players

WR TY Hilton 

Hilton is back with the Colts, turning down a deal with the Baltimore Ravens to return to Indianapolis despite two poor seasons. Even on his worst day, he is a quality speed receiver that can pop off a big play or two every game, and that is worth the cheap price he was retained for. Grade: B+

WR Zach Pascal

Pascal was stuck in restricted free agency limbo, but he has now been brought back to the Colts. On a team that was led by the slender Hilton out wide for years, a physical receiver like Pascal that can be trusted to win 50-50 balls has plenty of value. This might be the year he finally breaks out and challenges for 1,000 yards. Grade: B+

DE Al-Quadin Muhammad

Muhammad has spent the last three seasons with the Colts, recording five sacks along the way. While by no means much of a difference-maker, he’ll give a defensive line that is lacking in depth a fine backup. Low ceiling, but high floor as well. Grade: B-

RB Marlon Mack

For the Colts, this move makes sense, as Mack was a starter before his injury thrust Jonathan Taylor into the spotlight. Unfortunately, with Taylor the lead dog, Nyheim Hines still the pass-catching back, and young Jordan Wilkins still in the mix, it might be tough for Mack to carve out an on-field role on this team. Grade: C+

CB Xavier Rhodes

Retaining Rhodes was surprising, as he could’ve had his pick of huge offers after successfully establishing himself as a top-flite cornerback once again after a poor final season with the Minnesota Vikings. Rhodes is one of the anchors in a very deep secondary, and the Colts should be commended for finding a way to bring him back. Grade: A

Indianapolis Colts: 3 potential first-time starters who need to step up in 2021

If these three young players don't step up, the Indianapolis Colts' quest of winning the division could prove very difficult.