8 Best Indianapolis Colts NFL Draft Picks of All-Time
8 of 9
Defensive End Robert Mathis
The Colts got an absolute steal in the 2003 NFL Draft as Robert Mathis slipped all the way down to the fifth round and Indianapolis scooped him up with the 138th overall pick.
If the Colts knew Mathis was going to make five Pro Bowls and sack the quarterback 123 times in his career, they probably would’ve taken him sooner.
Indianapolis got 14 years of Hall of Fame level football from a player that most teams never even considered drafting.