4. ’18’: No, We’re Not Talking Peyton Manning
In Week 3 against the Tennessee Titans during the 2015 regular season, the Colts desperately needed a shot in the arm–trailing the Titans 24-14 on the road.
With 8:32 left in the 3rd quarter, Pat McAfee saw a deficiency in the Titans punt return alignment and improvised, as the punter fielded the snap only to tuck the football and run 18 yards on the right side for the first down–sparking the Colts eventual 35-33 comeback victory.